Roofing Warranties: Are You Having Productive Conversations?
One of the most overlooked opportunities in residential roofing sales is also one of the most powerful: the warranty discussion. Too often, warranties are treated as a piece of paper that gets handed to homeowners after the sale. In reality, a well-handled warranty conversation builds trust, differentiates your company, justifies premium pricing, and gives homeowners confidence in their buying decision.
The challenge is that many contractors aren’t comfortable with warranty discussions. In this article, I want to change that by detailing how contractors can use warranties as a powerful selling tool while helping homeowners better understand what they’re really buying.
First, it is important to explain the two types of warranties.
1. Product Warranty
This warranty is provided by the manufacturer and covers defects in the roofing materials themselves. In some cases, the coverage is for “manufacturer’s defects” only. These warranties can be problematic, as they place the onus on the property owner to prove a defect exists. In other cases, the product warranties spell out specific things that could go wrong, such as cracking, peeling, flaking, fading, chalking, and even wind failure. These warranties offer greater peace of mind for the consumer.
Product warranties vary dramatically from manufacturer to manufacturer. It is important to think of warranties as a legal contract between the seller and the buyer. As the contractors, it is critical to help homeowners understand:
- What is covered.
- What is not covered, and what limitations exist.
- What is the cap on the manufacturer’s maximum liability. In some cases, it may be the value of the original installed roof; in extreme cases, it may even be less than the value of the materials alone. This is a huge potential difference – be prepared to discuss it.
- Whether coverage diminishes over time – proration. If it does prorate, understand the proration schedule.
- Whether wind warranty coverage has an exclusion for named storms.
- Whether the warranty is transferable to subsequent homeowner(s).
Details matter when it comes to the product warranty. Be certain you understand the above and can explain it to your prospect for any products they are considering.
2. Workmanship Warranty
This warranty is provided by you, the contractor, and covers installation-related issues. It needs to be in writing and reviewed by legal counsel.
The best roofing systems will fail if improperly installed. That’s why homeowners should view the workmanship warranty as being every bit as important as the product warranty.
Similar to the product warranty, the workmanship warranty should have clearly defined coverage and exclusions/limitations. But keep in mind that contractors who stand behind their work demonstrate confidence, professionalism, and long-term commitment.
What Homeowners Really Want
After more than four decades in this industry, I’ve learned that homeowners want peace of mind, not a piece of paper.
The warranty is simply evidence that the manufacturer and contractor are confident in their product and willing to stand behind their promises.
That’s why the conversation should never begin with years, percentages, or legal language. Instead, start with confidence. Try saying: “The warranty isn’t the product. The warranty is evidence of the confidence we have in the product.”
Important Talking Points for Contractors
When helping homeowners appreciate the value of warranties, cover these key points.
“How long do you expect to own this home?”
This question helps determine which warranty features matter most. A homeowner planning to move in five years may place significant value on transferability. Someone planning to stay for decades may be more concerned with long-term protection.
“What happens if there is a problem?”
Most homeowners care less about legal terminology and more about practical outcomes. Explain clearly:
- Who they call if a problem occurs
- How claims are handled
- In what cases is labor covered
- How replacement materials are covered
“What does the warranty say about future value?”
Transferable warranties can enhance resale appeal and give future buyers confidence. For many homeowners, this is an important benefit.
“Who will still be here?”
A warranty is only as valuable as the company standing behind it. This is where established contractors and established manufacturers have a tremendous advantage. Discuss:
- Years in business
- Stability
- Industry reputation
- Track record of honoring commitments
The Most Powerful Warranty Question
If there is one question every contractor should ask, it is this:
“Would you rather have the longest warranty or the least chance of ever needing one?”
That question reframes the conversation as most homeowners quickly realize that durability, quality installation, and long-term performance matter more than simply chasing the largest number printed on a warranty certificate.
Final Thoughts
Many contractors unintentionally weaken their position by making statements such as:
- Don’t worry about the warranty.”
- “You’ll never need it.”
- “Everything has a lifetime warranty.”
Instead, use the warranty discussion as an opportunity to educate. The goal isn’t to overwhelm homeowners with legal details. The goal is to help them understand why your company, your installation practices, and your roofing system represent a lower-risk investment.
Premium roofing products require premium conversations. When handled properly, warranty discussions become far more than a review of paperwork. They become an opportunity to demonstrate expertise, establish trust, and reinforce the long-term value of the proposed roofing system.
Make sure that you’re the contractor who is willing to be transparent and talk openly about warranties.
And remember, homeowners don’t simply want a warranty. They want confidence that they have chosen the right contractor, the right manufacturer, and the right roof.
The contractors who learn to communicate that confidence effectively will close more sales, command higher margins, and build stronger customer relationships for years to come.
Contact me anytime you’d like to talk.
Todd Miller has spent his entire career in the metal building products manufacturing industry. He is president of Isaiah Industries, an organization recognized as one of the world’s leading metal roofing manufacturers. Todd is currently Vice President of the MRA (Metal Roofing Association) and a Past Chair of MCA (Metal Construction Association). Through his website, he strives to raise the bar on standards and practices to provide property owners with the best possible products for successful roofing projects.
You may pull quotes from this article provided you include a link back to the original article on this site. You may not reprint this full article, or even a significant amount of the article, without explicit permission. To gain permission, click here.
Leave a Reply